/
/
/
/
/
CRD vulnerable to trade restrictions with sewage P3

CRD vulnerable to trade restrictions with sewage P3

BURNABY—If local governments opt for public private partnerships (P3s), something which is under consideration for the Capital Regional District’s new sewage treatment, they are more vulnerable to the restrictions of the Canada-United States Procurement Agreement (CUPA).

A new legal opinion by Steven Shrybman of Sack Goldblatt Mitchell says the CUPA contains temporary rules that will make it difficult for the CRD to achieve environmental protection and local economic development objectives. Shrybman concludes that the best way to avoid the CUPA requirements is to go with conventional public procurement rather than a P3.

“This opinion should give elected councillors in the CRD cause for serious concern about what they will be able to achieve as part of the sewage treatment project if they opt for a P3. The CRD has placed a high priority on things like community economic development and environmental and resource conservation goals and they should have the right to pursue these goals,” said CUPE BC president Barry O’Neill.

In the 20 page opinion, Shrybman identifies a number of vulnerabilities for the CRD – including being prohibited from specifying some portion of local or even Canadian goods, services and labour and from supporting a market for innovative Canadian environmental or energy design or Canadian green technologies. He also cautions that the agreement creates a litigation risk arising from the rights US companies have under the CUPA to challenge both the method and the terms of certain CRD procurements.

Shrybman says that the conventional public approach to procurement offers several important advantages over a P3 model, allowing the sewage treatment project to avoid being captured by the CUPA rules.

The Canadian Union of Public Employees commissioned the opinion from Steven Shrybman of Sack Goldblatt Mitchell LLP Lawyers. A backgrounder and the full opinion are available at www.cupe.bc.ca/campaigns/water-watch/reports-research.

View backgrounder and opinion.

cope491
Share this
Share on facebook
Share on twitter

Latest News

Court ruling on Cambie clinic another stake in the heart for private health care, says CUPE BC

Court ruling on Cambie clinic another stake in the heart for private health care, says CUPE BC

July 15, 2022
VANCOUVER—Today’s ruling by the B.C. Court of Appeal dismissing a constitutional challenge by Brian Day and his Cambie Surgery Centre is another important win for public health care and a…
VANCOUVER—Today’s ruling by the B.C. Court of Appeal dismissing a constitutional challenge by Brian Day and his Cambie Surgery Centre is another important win for public health care and a...

CUPE welcomes new members at Summerland Community Support

CUPE welcomes new members at Summerland Community Support

July 11, 2022
SUMMERLAND – Workers at Summerland Community Support are the latest members to join B.C.’s largest union following a four-week education campaign. The newest CUPE members will become a new unit…
SUMMERLAND – Workers at Summerland Community Support are the latest members to join B.C.’s largest union following a four-week education campaign. The newest CUPE members will become a new unit...

Fraser River Indigenous Society workers join CUPE 1936 using new single-step certification

Fraser River Indigenous Society workers join CUPE 1936 using new single-step certification

July 6, 2022
CUPE is welcoming 16 new members at the Fraser River Indigenous Society where they will become the newest unit of Local 1936. These new members provide family development, early years…
CUPE is welcoming 16 new members at the Fraser River Indigenous Society where they will become the newest unit of Local 1936. These new members provide family development, early years...